IT WASN’T ME: By Len Kuntz
Monday, June 28th, 2010She begged us not to leave her alone but we did anyway. We could be mean when we wanted, cruel without trying.
When we got back from bowling, our little sister had locked us out of the house. We could hear the screams coming through the walls, a flock of magpie shrieks, a hundred horror movie murders taking place inside.
The earth burped, then shuddered and thunder clapped and several crows slammed into the window and slid down the cracked glass like oil stains.
It began to hail, a trillion little balls ice-picking our skin. The wind winged at us sideways, trying to tear us from the porch, trying to rip our limbs off.
I held onto Jerry because I was the elder twin by a minute, but my fingers had gone numb and he was rain-slickened. He yelled that he was sorry, so sorry for all the bad things he’d done in his life but he’d kept doing them because he got away with it, same as me, he said. Could we ever be forgiven, he asked, but by then Jerry was feet-off-the-air flying through the sky, down the street, going going gone.
A few moments later the storm stopped. Just stopped.
I tried the knob and walked in and she wasn’t anywhere.
I called, “Sarah. Sarah.” I searched behind doors and in every crawl space she favored.
I thought I caught a glimpse of her in the corner of the bathroom mirror holding a dagger shoulder-high, the large knife Mom used to part chicken, but when I wheeled around, the breeze ruffled the plastic shower curtain, showing me its culled and gleaming guts.
Across the tiled wall were the words EVERYTHING IS EVENTUAL. The words were written in crimson lipstick that bled red tears into the grout.
Around midnight the front door opened and my mother asked why I was sleeping on the couch. She looked pale and sauntered up the steps to bed.
My Dad sat down on the couch and patted my knee. “We lost him,” he said, and I told him I already knew that.
I said, “Jerry–he got blown away in the storm.”
My father’s cheek twitched and his eyes flickered, gauging me warily. “Who’s Jerry?” he asked. I forced a nervous laugh. “Hello?? Dad? Jerry, my brother?”
“That’s what I’m trying to tell you,” Dad said. “Your mom had another miscarriage, so your brother never made it into this world.”
I didn’t sleep that night. In the morning my sister was at the breakfast table. I asked, “What’re you doing here?”
“I live here, you stupid creep.”
“But I thought—“ I said, unable to continue.
“You thought, you thought.” My sister’s arms were crossed, eyes blazing.
“I don’t feel good. I think I’m staying home today.”
My sister took a gulp of orange juice and didn’t bother wiping her sopping lips. “You can’t stay home. Mom’s staying home. Mom lost the latest baby.”
My knees trembled when my sister withdrew a long knife with the serrated edge from the butcher block. “Look familiar?” she asked.
“We were only horsing around.”
She lifted the carving knife, then plunged it into a cube of soft butter. “Do you think it’s okay to go on torturing me, blaming someone else? Huh?” she spat, leaning forward.
“He said he was sorry. He didn’t mean all those things he did.”
“He?”
“Jerry?”
She leered. “Maybe you could look up the word accountability some day.”
“How’s that?”
“Jay, there’s no Jerry. Jerry is in your head, a scapegoat so you won’t feel guilty.”
“That’s not true. We’re, we’re twins.”
“Sure you are. And I’m Michelle Obama.”
“He and I are the same age, fourteen.”
“You’re the one, Jay. You’re the monster in this house. It’s all you.”
“But I-”
“That’s why Mom keeps losing the babies. They can sense how evil you are.”
“But it’s Jerry.”
My sister rounded the table fast as jaguar. She was different, still frightened but powerful now with the knife in her hand. She grasped my jaw, held the blade an inch from my face.
“Do you think I’m joking?” She asked.
I muttered, “No.”
Sickly streaks of butter dribbled off her fingertips.
“I’m doing you a favor here,” my sister said. “I’m killing the monster once and for all so you can have a normal life. Do you get that?”
I nodded.
“Do you mean it?”
“Of course.”
“So, you admit everything that’s happened, that it was all you?”
The knife tip moved closer. Reflected in the blade was a gray impression, almost a blemish. It shifted and moved in the metal.
“Say it was you. Say it, Jay, or die.”
The image took shape and Jerry looked back at me, that familiar smirk on his face, him always the confident one. He gave me a wink and mouthed the words, “Go ahead.”
Relief washed down my chest as I exhaled.
“It was you. Say it!”
The voice was mine but the words were his. “It was me.” Jerry took the blame because it was all his to take.
______________
©2010 Len Kuntz
Len Kuntz lives on a lake in rural Washington State with an eagle and three pesky beavers. His short fiction appears in places like Camroc Press Review, Right Hand Pointing and also at lenkuntz.blogspot.com .